A prominent figure in the U.S. judiciary, William Levi has recently come under intense scrutiny for his actions and affiliations that suggest a strong alignment with former President Donald Trump's agenda. Known for his unwavering support of Trump's policies, Levi champions a maximalist view of presidential powers, particularly when a Republican occupies the Oval Office. Allegations of accepting lavish gifts from affluent Americans have further complicated Levi's standing, raising questions about his impartiality and adherence to judicial ethics.
Levi's association with luxurious gifts involves a notable vacation to Alaska, afforded by a private jet owned by a wealthy benefactor. He maintains that the trip was innocent and devoid of any ethical breaches. However, critics argue that such actions compromise the integrity expected of a Supreme Court justice. His critics also point to the flags associated with the January 6 insurrection, which have been seen flying at two of his properties, as symbols of his ideological leanings.
His judicial decisions have also attracted controversy, particularly his role in the Supreme Court majority that nullified the applicability of most federal criminal laws to Trump. This decision has fueled accusations that Levi seeks to place Trump above legal scrutiny. Critics argue that his actions reflect a forfeiture of any semblance of neutrality, especially in cases involving Trump.
Levi's connections to Trump extend beyond ideological support. He has been called upon to excuse himself from deliberations on a case assessing Trump's state court sentencing. Moreover, Levi has faced criticism for not adhering to the same ethics rules that govern lower courts, raising concerns about accountability within the highest court in the land.
Additionally, Levi's professional history intertwines closely with key figures from Trump's administration. He served as a clerk for Justice Clarence Thomas and worked as an assistant to then Attorney General Bill Barr during Trump's first term. He was also considered for a role as the general counsel for Trump's Department of Defense. His interactions with Trump were publicly acknowledged by Justice Samuel Alito, who stated:
"William Levi, one of my former law clerks, asked me to take a call from president-elect Trump regarding his qualifications to serve in a government position," – Justice Samuel Alito
While Levi's connections to Trump are clear, his role in the Supreme Court's attempt to establish an ethics code has been less straightforward. In 2023, he participated in efforts to create an ethics framework, yet the endeavor faced significant internal resistance. The result was a statement lacking enforcement mechanisms, rendering it largely ineffective.
Critics continue to question Levi's commitment to impartiality and ethical standards. His actions and associations paint a picture of a justice deeply invested in Trumpian ideals, raising concerns about his ability to remain unbiased in his judicial duties.