The New Orleans archdiocese has found itself at the center of controversy following its bankruptcy filing, as it seeks contributions from affiliates, including the Second Harvest food bank. This move has sparked outrage among community leaders and former board members, who argue that diverting funds intended for feeding the hungry to settle child molestation claims is morally indefensible.
The archdiocese declared bankruptcy due to mounting legal fees — surpassing $40 million over a five-year period — and has asked its affiliates to assist in covering settlements related to abuse claims against Catholic clergy. Among those affiliates, Second Harvest has been asked to contribute up to $16 million, a request that led to the removal of its longtime president and CEO, Natalie Jayroe, along with three board members, including James Adams.
The decision to oust Jayroe and the board was made by Archbishop Aymond after they refused to send funds to the archdiocese to help pay the settlements. Adams expressed his surprise, stating that he did not understand why Second Harvest was listed among those expected to contribute, especially as none of the abuse claims are connected to the food bank's operations.
“I worked closely with Jayroe and others at Second Harvest to help raise $15 million for the food bank over the years,” Adams said. He emphasized the importance of honoring commitments made to donors who support Second Harvest's mission.
In light of the archdiocese's financial tactics, Adams remarked, “Taking money that’s specifically given to help feed those who are the poorest among us… and using it to pay for the actions of pedophile priests is absolutely in direct contrast to the teachings of Christ, direct contrast to what we should be doing as church.”
Community leaders have voiced their disapproval. Sidney Arroyo, a retired political strategist, stated he was “livid” upon hearing that Second Harvest might be compelled to contribute to the bankruptcy settlement. “I think that’s not only unacceptable, I think it’s disgusting,” he said.
In addition to the backlash, Second Harvest is bound by contracts with major donors like Feeding America and the MacKenzie Scott Foundation, which recently awarded the food bank $25 million. Feeding America issued a statement affirming their commitment to ensuring resources are used for their intended purposes. “When people invest in our mission, we must strive to honor our commitment to them and to people facing hunger,” the organization stated.
Archbishop Aymond had previously indicated that ministries, schools, and parishes would not be required to contribute to the bankruptcy settlement. However, the inclusion of Second Harvest in this request raises concerns about the precedent it sets for other dedicated church funds.
As the archdiocese initiates a campaign to raise $75 million for restoring St. Louis Cathedral in New Orleans, many are questioning the priorities of church leadership. The financial strain on the archdiocese has prompted calls for transparency and accountability regarding its handling of funds intended for charitable purposes.
Despite these developments, the archdiocese has yet to respond to inquiries from WWL Louisiana regarding this contentious issue. The future remains uncertain for both Second Harvest and those reliant on its services as community leaders continue to advocate against using charitable funds in this manner.