In a shocking case that has captivated the nation, 14 members of a religious sect known as the Saints have been sentenced for the manslaughter of eight-year-old Elizabeth Struhs. The young girl died after suffering diabetic ketoacidosis over a four-day period, a condition that was exacerbated by the sect members' refusal to administer life-saving insulin. The court found that the sect members, including Elizabeth’s parents, demonstrated deliberate neglect leading to her death.
Elizabeth's tragic demise unfolded in Toowoomba, Australia, where the sect members resided. The group, led by Brendan Stevens, used coercion and manipulation to exert control over their family members and others within the community. Justice Martin Burns, who presided over the case, delivered scathing remarks during sentencing.
"You allowed your faith to blind you to her real plight," – Justice Martin Burns
The court proceedings revealed that the sect members had previously failed to provide Elizabeth with the necessary care in 2019. Despite these warnings, they continued to prioritize their religious beliefs over her health, ultimately resulting in her tragic death.
Brendan Stevens, deemed the leader of the sect, received a 13-year prison sentence. Justice Burns highlighted the manipulative influence Stevens had over both his family and others.
"You are a dangerous, highly manipulative individual and the authorities would be wise to consider that on your release from prison," – Justice Martin Burns
Elizabeth's father, Jason Struhs, faced a 14.5-year sentence, with a minimum of 80% to be served behind bars. Meanwhile, her mother, Kerrie Struhs, received a sentence slightly exceeding 15 years. The remaining sect members were sentenced to between six and seven years in prison.
"Elizabeth suffered a slow and painful death and you are all in one way or another responsible." – Justice Martin Burns
The court acknowledged the sect's profound indoctrination, which led them to believe their actions were justified despite the obvious harm it caused to Elizabeth. They allowed their faith to dictate their actions, ignoring the stark reality of Elizabeth’s deteriorating condition.
"You put your own personal beliefs ahead of your duty and then staked the life of your eight-year-old child on it." – Justice Martin Burns
Elizabeth’s brother, Zachary Struhs, also received a six-year prison sentence. The court recognized that the sect's teachings blurred the line between faith and neglect, ultimately endangering Elizabeth’s life.
"Your prospects of rehabilitation are bleak, to say the least …," – Justice Martin Burns
Jayde Struhs, another family member affected by Brendan Stevens’ influence, expressed deep condemnation of the sect's practices.
"The coercion and the manipulation Brendan used to control not only his own family, but mine is the most unforgivable and disgusting abuse of people’s vulnerability." – Jayde Struhs
Justice Burns issued a stern warning about the future conduct of those involved, emphasizing that they should not be entrusted with the care or custody of any child without strict supervision.
"It is my opinion that you should have nothing at all to do with the care or custody of any child, and nor should you ever have direct or indirect contact with the child unless any such contact is strictly supervised." – Justice Martin Burns
Despite their lengthy sentences, some sect members may be eligible for parole after serving a certain percentage of their time, with some potentially eligible within three years. This provision has raised concerns among those who believe the sect members' ability to reintegrate safely into society remains questionable.